Fixing a hole
There's big news over at Willamette Weed. They're starting up a nonprofit organization that will engage in investigative journalism around Oregon and have its stories run in local media outlets in the covered areas. And like the man says, "We're putting our best people on it." Nigel Jaquiss, the Jack Ruby of Portland journalism, is involved, as is long-time Weed boss Mark Zusman.
Exactly how it is all going to work is not crystal clear to me at the moment. But the "statewide civic newsroom" will be called "Oregon Journalism Project," and it will be somehow affiliated with an established national outfit called Alternative Newsweekly Foundation. Apparently the structure they're using, or something like it, is working in a few other states.
It appears that some of the articles will be produced by students majoring in journalism in college. I can relate personally to the value of that, particularly if the students get paid something decent for their work. But there is never going to be enough money in newspaper subscriptions, their online equivalents, and advertising to make local news profitable in most places, even if people are willing to write for peanuts. And so the nonprofit setup allows rich folk to make tax-deductible donations that ultimately pay writers and editors.
The arrangement will not be entirely separate from the Weed. Not only will some of the new organization's content appear in that publication, but the project website also refers to "Willamette Week, from which our back-office services are provided via a service agreement." I assume that the nonprofit will pay the Weed for the services provided under the agreement, which could lead to some interesting entanglements.
But whatever the details will be, far be it from me to deny that local journalism in the state is on its death bed, if not already in its grave. For instance, here's a news nugget on the project's website that I had not heard before:
In Portland, the New York City-owned newspaper The Oregonian is a shadow of its former self — with newsroom staff down 90% in just 10 years, it now operates remotely with a skeleton crew and is expected to stop printing this year, as have other newspapers in this chain.
Is the O going online-only soon? Big news, I suppose, although I have not held a hard copy of that product in my hands for many years.
A new model for journalism will take some getting used to, but somebody needs to be keeping an eye on all those giant vats of public money to which the politicians and bureaucrats have access. I hope this project can make a real mark as a watchdog, and that the model doesn't lead any well-intentioned people into trouble.
Journalism’s pretty much disappeared in the Portland area. It’s been replaced by passive lip service to real news and active support for the agendas of the editors and producers. Some call the local reporting a lazy effort. In most businesses, a lazy effort would immediately lead to termination.
ReplyDeleteSounds like more pro-government news outlets.
ReplyDeleteEeyore is in the house!
DeleteI get the Sunday paper in the flesh. For quite some time I received emails with deals for it and the online version. Deals for the Sunday paper stopped a couple of months ago, and I wondered if they were going to cease print production. Reading a tablet with one's Sunday breakfast is just not the same as turning actual pages.
ReplyDeleteIf this is what's required to "save local journalism," bid adieu to local journalism. Nigel has been running on the fumes of his Pulitzer for years; WillyWeek is evaporating and has never said a nasty word about Ellen Rosenblum. They completely ignored the development of the radical new city charter and are now playing catchup. Looks more like a retirement project for the old warhorses and, probably, a way to cash out as a nonprofit.
ReplyDeleteNot promising.
As I say, this sort of thing is being tried in other places as well. With news media unable to make a profit, might as well organize as a nonprofit! But you do have to wonder how "independent" they are when their paychecks depend on wealthy benefactors. The same concern always used to be there with advertisers, I suppose.
DeleteOn a different front, it's a bit disheartening to see journalism join the nonprofit industrial complex. The complex has already captured state and local government, and now the media. "Our community partners." Formerly known as "our unemployable cronies."
Substack is where it's at. I learn more about local affairs there than anywhere else.
ReplyDeleteOregonCitizen.com has an excellent article on Hacienda a partially state funded organization on Killingsworth, that is handing out 21 grants of $30K for new home-ownership, provided by SB1529 passed in 2022, which there own counsel said violated the equal indeminty clause essentially and yet still passed it. The qualifications for the grant recipients; non-citizens. Make Oregon less like Oregon.
ReplyDeleteEqual indemnity clause? What's that?
Deleteexplain it to us, i was being obtuse to elicit articulation, jack
DeleteIt makes no sense The Oregonian to reprint day-old news stories that everyone has already read online. Instead, they should focus on local news, local crime, investigative journalism and good old muckraking that is popular with subscribers. When I travel and pick up the paper, I immediately pull out the Local News section and think many others do the same. There is a good book called Emus Loose in Egnar that features local publications that thrived in this new landscape. Close to home, look at the truly incredible job Allan Classen does with the NW Examiner.
ReplyDelete