Step on the gas and wipe that tear away
The O has a story behind the Paywall of Pity today about how taxpayers and their income are running out of Multnomah County in droves. If you're like me, you're not paying to see what the O is offering these days, but the article is based on public data from the IRS, which has an army of statisticians keeping track of county-to-county migration patterns, based on tax returns filed. I've looked at some of the government tables on which the O article is based, and here's what I see from my amateur perch.
For the tax year 2021, the number of individual tax returns filed from zip codes in Multnomah County fell by 5,591. Of the returns filed from Multnomah the previous year, 316,329 stayed in the county, but 35,364 were filed from somewhere else. Meanwhile, 29,773 returns that were filed from somewhere else the year before were filed in Multnomah. The 5,591 net decrease in returns (35,364 out minus 29,773 in) represents about a 1.61 percent drop from the previous year.
But the taxpayers who left had a lot of income. Get this: The adjusted gross income on tax returns filed in Multnomah County for 2021 was $1,080,279,000 less than for 2020. If I've got my numbers straight, that's a decrease of about 3.82 percent in a single year. But for sure, it's more than a billion bucks! The details are: $2,021,084,000 migrating in, and $3,101,163,000 migrating out. (Meanwhile, the people who stayed from the previous year showed adjusted gross income totaling about $28.2 billion.)
Statewide, Oregon isn't doing so great, but it's nowhere near in the trouble Multnomah County's in. The state had out-migration of $5,195,965,000 and in-migration of $5,029,643,000, for a net loss of $122.3 million, or by my numbers a decline of less than a tenth of a percent. If you take Multnomah County out of the equation, Oregon as a whole is doing fine.
Things are really swinging in Clackistan, though. Clackamas County had out-migration of $1,230,005,000 and in-migration of $1,549,928,000. That's an increase in income of approximately $319.9 million, or by calculations about 1.95 percent.
Over in Washington County, not so good. The out-migration was $1,965,227,000 and the in-migration was only $1,502,807,000. That's a loss of $453.4 million, or I think about 2.08 percent from the year before.
The numbers speak for themselves, but I guess there are a couple of other points worth making. The zip codes that control this study are about a year old. The returns from which they were taken were filed in the spring, summer, and fall of 2022, as the taxpayers were reporting income from 2021. I would think that when the IRS releases its annual report next year on returns being filed now, in 2023, Multnomah County's numbers will not be improving.
And remember, while these income figures are depressing, Portland City Hall's balance sheet is even worse. We are in the fourth-worst shape of the top 75 cities in the country when it comes to comparing assets to liabilities. There is no pot of cash to cushion the fall.
So when you list Portland's woes, leave some room for financial collapse. The future is not looking bright in that department.
I found the most surprising aspect in that article (and the data) was that Washington County had an outflow. I wonder if some of the zip codes which are shared with Multnomah county played a role in this?
ReplyDeleteThey lost only 755 returns, but $453.4 million. That's something like $600K per return. There must have been a few "whales" among those leaving.
DeleteIn contrast, Multnomah lost about $193K per exiting return.
Delete97229, which I know well, includes very high income areas of both Multnomah and Washington counties. Does the data just show a move from 97229, or does it go deeper to get to which county it represents?
ReplyDeleteThe IRS explains its methodology here: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-soi/2021inpublicmigdoc.pdf
DeleteAs best I can tell, they use nine-digit zip codes, as tied to particular counties by the Census Bureau.
Business is booming here in Lake O, with new stuff going up on a fairly regular basis. I kind of miss the old “village” feel, but there are still many remnants left.
ReplyDeleteI can only imagine that Tigard, Beaverton, and Hillsboro are also reaping the rewards from the great Portland exodus. If I had the means, and I still lived there, I would flee also.
Clackamas County is looking good to the IRS. For some odd reason, Washington County isn't.
DeleteMolalla beckons then!
ReplyDeleteThe only way to bring those people back is to improve public transit and add more bike lanes.
ReplyDeleteYou forgot to add the "/snark" to your post...unless, that is, you are serious? If you are serious I'd point out that more bike lanes would just give you more opportunities to be run over in the mayhem that is Portland's streets. And, on the subject of taking mass transit: only the desperate or the delusional take mass transit in Portland these days. Oh sure, save the planet by taking mass transit...just make sure you have 2x the time available to get anywhere and be sure to have good running shoes on and the skills to use them as you may need to flee for your life from some random crazy/homeless person that's sharing the ride with you. Just saying...
Delete...and more "safe rest villages"... Oh yeah...make fentanyl free & hand out tinfoil, lighters and straws to be able to smoke it. But what about "booting" supplies, you may ask...
DeleteWith more tents, needle exchange locations and free spray paint cans
DeleteBurn first than pillage.
DeleteThe joint plan of Multnomah County and the city of Portland to control housing prices by reducing demand by increasing taxes and reducing the quality of life is beginning to work.
ReplyDeleteAren’t the numbers only going to get worse for Multnomah, with its extremely high level of income taxation kicking in?
ReplyDeleteYou just know that there are a fair number of kooks out there that will bite the bullet and hold their ground just to “prove a point.”
DeleteYou know, the “things happen in a big city”, and the “bye-bye rich people” types. They will double-down on their insanity just to prove a point.
Well the good news, San Francisco is still far more beyond recovery than we are. There is always a silver crack pipe, err I mean lining.
ReplyDelete